Publication Does Not a Writer Make (What Exactly Makes a Writer a Writer?)

I was at a writer’s conference not long ago, and one of the speakers said something disturbing. Like most such conferences, there were writers of varying genres present as well as several editors and agents and such. The disturbing speaker was the editor of a Poetry magazine and, while she was encouraging local poets to submit their work during panel time, she quipped, “You should submit your work. Because you are not a real writer until you’ve sent your work out there to be read.”

Now I know the editor meant well, and I appreciate that she was encouraging writers to submit their work for possible publication. I think that’s great, but…



You’re not a writer until you are submitting for publication?! Not until other people read my writing, am I a writer?!

Several others in the room were nodding their heads, and a flurry of “wannabes” were thinking, “Man, I gotta get my stuff out there, since I’m not a writer yet! What am I even doing at a writer’s conference?”

Meanwhile I shook my head and cringed quite a bit as the panel moved on. There was a New York Times bestselling writer there as well. One who had traveled a fairly long and rocky road to publication. And she was cringing visibly too.

She didn’t speak up, but I wish she would have, because she was on the panel too. And because that editor’s notion of what constitutes a writer was complete rubbish. She knew it, and so did I.

A writer is someone who writes.

If you have written, then you are a writer!

You are not defined by your publication status.

Nor are you defined by your readership.

Screen Shot 2014-09-15 at 8.07.57 AMEmily Dickinson was published largely post-humously. Stieg Larsson’s Millenium trilogy was published after his death, before he had a single one of the millions of readers he has today (outside of his journalism of course).

This sort of notion that submission and publication deems one a writer is disturbing and harmful to writers everywhere, and I think it is a common mentality among folks in the “biz” as well as the so-called “wannabe” writers. To say nothing of the assumption that “house” publication is the only path to readership, and therefore to being considered a “true” writer.

I may not have a readership for years. And there is nothing wrong with that. I have spent countless hours writing, and that makes me a writer. And it makes you one too.

firstDraftYou are a writer during the first draft, and the first novel you decided you hated and trashed, and the one you submitted but which was rejected by a hundred agents and editors, and the one you self-published to small fan-fare, as well as the piece of writing which got you readership and broke out, or whatever.

Publication is not the point, and neither are the readers.

They are handy when they come. Sure. But failure and rejection and crappy first novels (or seconds or thirds) are all a part of the process of growing as a writer. Not the path from wannabe to actual writer. Stephen King threw out the original draft of Carrie because he thought it garbage. Had his wife not discovered it in the trash and read it and told him he had something going there and to keep writing it, we might not be reading it in droves still forty years later. Along with all his other stories for that matter. Who knows? But he was a writer then as much as now.

You don’t become a writer once people appreciate it. People have simply discovered you are a writer once they are able to read what you wrote. And incidentally, it doesn’t take a magazine or house to get there. It can, but it is not a requirement.

If you’ve written, you are a writer. So enough with all that crap. Keep writing, because you are a writer and you have to write. Not so you can become a writer. But because you are a writer, and that is what you do.

No matter who has discovered your writing yet.

Published by s.a.klopfenstein

I write epic fantasy novels, and I sometimes write a few blogs, mostly concerning what I am learning about writing and my own publishing journey.

2 thoughts on “Publication Does Not a Writer Make (What Exactly Makes a Writer a Writer?)

  1. You’re an amazing person to write this. It’s fascinating how much power publishers and editors have when they’ve got such short attention spans and overheads to consider when publishing novels. I read a blog from an editor who said that what essays or stories get published in the international publication she edits depends on her mood that day and she likes to make fun of the writers who submit their work and even toss the paper submissions in the trash. Apparently, she has no time to sift through it. Her advice, “you just have to be lucky because it’s all about timing”. It was very disconcerting to read. I also find it amusing when these powerful editors lose their jobs and now want to publish books of their own. They end up writing columsn for gossip magazines and lamenting their inability to get published, etc. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for reading! That is a disconcerting post from that editor. There is definitely an element of luck to catching the right person’s eye in the industry, but that is true in self-publishing too, just in a different sense… I don’t mean this to be a bash of editors, or the publishing industry either… I think there are wonderful editors (I’ve met some great ones), and publishing in a house can be a wonderful experience as well, but it is not the Be-All-End-All for writers. That is simply getting good at writing.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: